A coroner’s inquest in Prince Albert, Saskatchewan, is scrutinizing the police use of force that contributed to the 2023 death of 40-year-old Boden Umpherville, with officers testifying this week about the escalation of a traffic stop that turned fatal.
Officers recount escalation during arrest attempt
On April 1, 2023, police stopped a vehicle on the 1200 block of 13 Street West after it was reported stolen. According to testimony, officers discovered warrants for Umpherville’s arrest on drug charges and breach of release, prompting an attempt to detain him as a passenger in the car.
Prince Albert Police Sgt. Ryan Banadyga, one of the first officers on scene, described Umpherville’s resistance as unprecedented. “I have never seen such resistance and strength,” Banadyga testified, detailing how officers used tasers, batons, and physical force in an effort to subdue him.
During the struggle, Umpherville reportedly moved from the passenger seat to the driver’s seat before the vehicle accelerated and struck a police car. Banadyga said he grabbed Umpherville’s arm and pulled with “all the strength I had” to remove him from the vehicle.
Medical testimony and officer accounts diverge
Video footage shown at the inquest depicts Umpherville surrounded and held down by four to five officers after being pulled from the car. While Banadyga stated he monitored Umpherville’s vitals and breathing, Const. Amanda Boland testified she did not observe any medical assessment until paramedics arrived.
Saskatchewan’s chief forensic pathologist testified Tuesday that Umpherville suffered cardiac arrest due to asphyxia and drug use, which went unnoticed for too long. Banadyga told the inquest, “I would never have assumed that he was in medical distress.”
Boland also confirmed striking Umpherville’s back with her knee while he was in handcuffs, a detail that emerged during cross-examination.
Police morale and potential reforms under review
The Serious Incident Response Team (SIRT) cleared the officers of wrongdoing in 2023, but the inquest has become a focal point for police morale. Prince Albert Police Association President Darcy Bear described the atmosphere as one of “fear of repercussions for decisions made in the heat of the moment.”
Bear indicated officers are open to recommendations from the inquest, including the implementation of body-worn cameras. The outcome of the hearing is expected to shape future policing protocols in the region.
The inquest continues, with further testimony expected in the coming days.
